The Student - Anton Chekhov, 1894

남준표

    The story was very interesting in that we can find the Hero’s journey in such a short story. The most interesting part to me was the third part, refusal of the call. In the story, protagonist refuses the call of adventure, not by his own will, but by his feeling that he doe not want to go home. I was a bit confused about considering this as a refusal, but, the decision was made by the protagonist. He did not want to go home, because of many reasons, he was hungry but there were no food to eat. In my opinion, there was a quick, a real short refusal of the call, which suddenly changed, and lead Ivan to his adventure. 

    What made me astonished was how Chekhov wrote this story, because it is really abnormal. A boy on a journey and achieves two women crying. To me I can’t understand the purpose of this short story.  Maybe that was because of my lack of understanding of how Russia was going on at that time, maybe because I lacked background informations or else. 

183 words

6/10

댓글

  1. Garrioch2022년 3월 16일 오후 4:44

    Good analysis, and you clearly understand the refusal of the call, even though this story doesn't really need it. Only Vasilisa cry, but her tears are sort of Ivan's confirmation that he has a future as a priest in the church. You write well and have deep thoughts, so I hope you can keep up and not fall behind. Each story should only require a few minutes of typing and you don't need to be as detailed as this. You can just share your thoughts freely without research. Do not overlook the reading journal. It is more important then exams.

    답글삭제

댓글 쓰기

이 블로그의 인기 게시물

Araby - 1914

 Araby 남준표 7/10     Araby moved my heart. The boy’s perspective over crush is something familiar, something usual at our age. It could be a impure love of boy in our perspective, but to me, love the boy feels felt something pure. In contrast with the last scene in the story, boy acts himself to be in favor of Mangan’s sister. On the other hand, the other 2 men and a sales woman is love for one’s greed. In my opinion, real love, is something about sacrifice. One sacrificing oneself for each other, one who can rely in hard times is real love.       Love for greed is kind of a human society problem. In state of poverty, one would only be focusing on their survival. But as society grows, it gave us too much. We own more than we need, but we desire more. Each other benefiting for their greed. I’m not saying it is something bad. We all look for the most benefit for oneself.      Araby gave me a mixed feeling on the end, because it is a growing...
자세한 내용 보기

The lady with the dog

 The lady with the dog 201043 남준표 1899/12     To me this story was rather boring as we are living in the 21st century. But to speak for the people who might have first read the kind of a story might have been felling weird, because it is something out of our common sense, like we don’t usually fall in love with person who is married, But at the same time, they would be so curious of how the story will progress. Me too, felt the same when I watched these types of Dramas. Also, the format, divided in many sections were interesting.      I focused on how the relation will lead on. First, the protagonist have stereotypes  toward woman. To me the relationship will tear down soon, and they will return to their life as it used to be. According to Martin Heidegger langeweile is a feeling we feel when we lose something. Thing we usually dont take a big care will change if you lose that, arousing the sense of emptyness. langeweile will be felt to the too people ...
자세한 내용 보기